What to Do in Spiritual Desolation: A Catholic Guide to Getting Through the Darkness

Blog

You sat down to pray and felt… nothing. No warmth. No presence. Just silence and the weight of your own thoughts. Maybe it’s been days. Maybe weeks. You keep showing up — the rosary, the morning offering, even Mass — and it all feels mechanical. Hollow. Like God packed up and left without telling you.

If that’s where you are right now, you’re experiencing what the Catholic tradition calls spiritual desolation. And the most important thing you need to hear is this: it doesn’t mean you’ve done something wrong. It doesn’t mean God has abandoned you. And it doesn’t mean your faith is dying.

It means something is happening beneath the surface — something the saints understood well.

What Spiritual Desolation Actually Is

St. Ignatius of Loyola, who mapped the interior life more carefully than perhaps any saint before or since, defined spiritual desolation in his Spiritual Exercises as “darkness of soul, turmoil within it, an impulsive motion toward low and earthly things, or disquiet from various agitations and temptations.” He contrasted it with consolation — that felt sense of God’s closeness, warmth in prayer, and desire for holy things.

But here’s what most people miss: desolation is not the same as depression, and consolation is not the same as happiness. You can be experiencing real suffering and still have spiritual consolation — a deep trust that God is present. And you can have a perfectly comfortable life and be drowning in spiritual desolation — a restless emptiness that nothing fills.

The Catechism names this directly: “The habitual difficulty in prayer is distraction… another difficulty, especially for those who sincerely want to pray, is dryness” (CCC 2729). It acknowledges that dryness belongs to contemplative prayer “when the heart is separated from God, with no taste for thoughts, memories, and feelings, even spiritual ones” (CCC 2731).

This is normal. This is ancient. And the tradition gives you very concrete guidance on what to do about it.

What to Do in Spiritual Desolation: 6 Practices from St. Ignatius and the Saints

St. Ignatius didn’t just describe desolation — he gave rules for surviving it. These aren’t abstract theology. They’re field-tested instructions for the moments when God feels a thousand miles away.

1. Never Make a Major Change During Desolation

This is Ignatius’s most famous rule, and it’s the one people break most often. When you’re in desolation, every spiritual commitment you’ve made will feel pointless. You’ll want to quit your prayer routine, skip confession, stop going to daily Mass, pull back from the community that supports you.

Don’t. Ignatius warns that in desolation, the enemy “works to crush us and bring us down by his deceits and false reasonings” (Spiritual Exercises, Rule 5). The feelings are real, but the conclusions they suggest are not. If you decided to pray the morning offering when you were at peace, keep praying it when you’re in darkness. The commitment stands even when the feeling doesn’t.

2. Actively Resist — Don’t Just Endure

Ignatius’s Rule 6 is surprising: he says you should not only maintain your spiritual practices but intensify them. Pray longer, not shorter. Add a spiritual practice, don’t subtract one. Fast more. Examine your conscience more carefully.

This sounds counterintuitive — and that’s the point. Desolation tempts you toward passivity, toward giving up. Ignatius says to push back. Not because effort earns grace, but because active resistance breaks the pattern of spiritual paralysis.

Practically, this might mean:

Adding ten minutes of lectio divina to your routine
Praying an extra decade of the rosary
Going to confession even though you don’t feel like it
Doing a more thorough examination of conscience at night

3. Remember That It Will Pass

Ignatius’s Rule 8 tells the person in desolation to “strive to abide in patience, which is the virtue opposed to the troubles that harass them.” Patience here isn’t passive waiting — it’s the active conviction that this season has an end.

The Psalms model this. Psalm 22 opens with “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” — words of raw desolation. But it doesn’t end there. By verse 24: “For he has not despised or scorned the suffering of the afflicted one; he has not hidden his face from him but has listened to his cry.” The Psalmist holds both the darkness and the promise simultaneously.

Every saint who experienced deep desolation — and nearly all of them did — came through the other side. That’s not wishful thinking. It’s the consistent testimony of two thousand years of Catholic spiritual life.

4. Look for the Cause — Gently

Ignatius identifies three possible causes of desolation (Spiritual Exercises, Rule 9):

Our own negligence — we’ve let prayer slip, avoided the sacraments, drifted from the habits that kept us close to God
A test — God permits desolation to show us what our faith is actually made of, stripped of pleasant feelings
A lesson in humility — to teach us that consolation is a gift, not something we earn or control

Notice: only the first one involves any fault on your part. And even then, the response isn’t guilt — it’s simply returning to the spiritual habits you’ve stepped away from.

If you can’t identify any negligence, the desolation likely falls into category two or three. God isn’t punishing you. He’s refining you.

5. Talk to Someone

Ignatius compares the enemy’s strategy to that of a “false lover” who thrives on secrecy (Spiritual Exercises, Rule 13). Desolation gains power when you keep it to yourself. It whispers that no one would understand, that your dryness is proof of some private spiritual failure.

Break the silence. Talk to a spiritual director, a priest in confession, or a trusted friend who shares your faith. Simply naming what you’re going through — “I’m in a season of spiritual dryness and I don’t know why” — strips the desolation of much of its power.

If you don’t have a spiritual director, your parish priest is a good starting point. Even a single conversation can bring remarkable clarity.

6. Cling to What You Know, Not What You Feel

This is the deepest lesson of desolation, and the one the saints return to again and again. Faith is not a feeling. The truths you professed at your baptism, the Real Presence you receive in the Eucharist, the mercy spoken over you in confession — none of these depend on your emotional state.

St. John of the Cross, who wrote the definitive Catholic text on spiritual darkness (Dark Night of the Soul), taught that God sometimes withdraws the felt sense of His presence precisely to move us from a faith built on feelings to a faith built on naked trust. The “dark night” is not a punishment — it’s a passage. God is weaning you off spiritual milk so you can receive solid food (cf. Hebrews 5:12-14).

“In the dark night of the soul, bright flows the river of God.” — St. John of the Cross

When Desolation Lasts: Lessons from Mother Teresa and St. Thérèse

Sometimes desolation isn’t a bad week. It’s years.

When Mother Teresa’s private letters were published in Come Be My Light (2007), the world discovered that she had experienced nearly fifty years of spiritual darkness — from 1948 until her death in 1997. She wrote to her spiritual director: “In my soul I feel just that terrible pain of loss, of God not wanting me, of God not being God, of God not really existing.”

And yet she never stopped. She served. She prayed. She received the Eucharist daily. She founded a religious order. She became one of the most recognizable faces of Christian love in the twentieth century — all while feeling nothing.

St. Thérèse of Lisieux experienced a similar “trial of faith” in the last eighteen months of her life, writing that she was surrounded by “a wall which reaches right up to the heavens” and that the thought of heaven produced only “conflict and torment.”

These women are not cautionary tales. They’re proof that holiness has never required good feelings. Their perseverance in desolation was their holiness.